The Critic

  • About

Recent Posts

  • VEER : This VEER is Weird!
  • Chance Pe Dance: No Chance!
  • Raat Gayi Baat Gayi? : Articulate, Artistic, Adult Comedy
  • 3 idiots: idio-logic works!
  • Rab Ne Bana Di Jodi : Shahaditya!

Tag Cloud

    3 Idiots 3 idiots movie review 3idtios review Aamir Khan Avatar bollyood movies Bollywood bollywood film review Bollywood Movie Reviews Chetan Bhagat DharamVeer Dharamvir film reviews Five Point Someone Hindi Film Review hindi films Hindi Films Review Hindi Movie Review hindi movies Hollywood Indian Films Reviews Indian Movie Reviews Jaane tu…ya jaane na Madhavan Mission Istanbul: Mithoon Chakraborti Movie Reviews Jaane tu…ya jaane na Munnabhai lage raho Munnabhai MBBS Rab Ne Bana Di Jodi Raju Hirani Salman Khan santa Sharman Joshi Veer Veer Movie Review Veer Review Vidhu Vinod Chopra Vir Xmas

Archives

  • January 2010
  • December 2009
  • December 2008
  • August 2008
  • July 2008
  • June 2008
  • April 2008
  • March 2008
  • February 2008
  • January 2008
  • December 2007
  • November 2007

VEER : This VEER is Weird!

January 23rd, 2010

The Great Hindi Film Industry has come a long way from the black and white, silent movies era. Now we can boast of the best technicians and best quality of production on our films. Sadly, we can not say that about content and storytelling. This can be because the people who did the films earlier, did not had any ready references to follow. They had complex and hard life which had enriched them with experiences which could make great stories.

Now with the globalization, every country in the world is getting structured in a same template. So the emotions and experiences are similar all over. Due to this, suddenly there is nothing new to express as everyone is having same kind of smoothed out experiences.

In such scenario the film makers use old hit machines as references and try to put multiple such movies into one movie. Veer is such kind of movie. It uses elements from Troy, Gladiator and even our own DharamVeer. We have nothing to complain, if the movie is able to create an enchanting experience for us for the 2-3 hours of length it has. As long as it entertains the audience, they do not worry if its a copy or a remake or an adaptation. The experience shall be entertaining or engaging.

15 mins into Veer and you feel that the makers got it right this time. They are able to create a great adrenalin pumping experience for us. The audience blow whistles and applaud to even the entry of the infant VEER assuming he is the infant Salman. The pre-release euphoria about Salman and the movie building a charged up atmosphere in the movie hall. This is the love, trust and hope audience has for Salman Khan.

But …..

I do not like these buts… but… they are are there in many major movies recently.

The But Effect acts…. the movie goes into sleep mode once Salman catches the glimpse of a princes while doing the train robbery.

Before that and more, let me tell you the background. Before independence, there was a community in Rajputana called Pindhari which is infamous for their drunken brutal ways of fighting a war. Often addressed in the movie as barbaric Pindhari, they are great warriors and are honest people in reality.

Prithvi Singh aka Dadda (Mithoon Chakraborti) is head of this clan who helps the King of Madhavgarh, Raja Gyanedra (Jackie Shroff) to win a war in lieu of a land they demand. Instead of fulfilling the promise, the king brutally kills the 4500 Pindharis with the help of the british army and canons. Though able to run away from the disaster, Prithvi Singh take oath for revenge and pride.

They get dispersed in different areas of the state to prepare their soldiers for war with Madhavgarh and the British. As the time flies, Prithvi has 2 young boys who grow up to be great warriors, Veer (Salman Khan) and Punya (Sohail Khan). Veer as mentioned above meets his dreamgirl in a train robbery where they try to get back the treasure which British are supposedly stealing from India (What was the princes doing in that train then?). Prithvi sends them to study in London where Veer very conveniently meets the girl just later to know that she studies in same college. What a coincidence ?

Veer learns the British ways and methods to equip himself with better knowledge and strategy to defeat them in their own game when time demands. Now what happens with him love story and his daddu’s revenge story, you can try to check out if you decide to watch this movie.

So till the time Salman meets his girl, the movie is very promising and engrossing. But as the love story starts unfolding, the writer goes out of Ideas. The director keeps rolling the valuable film stock to shoot stale moments which are unsuccessful in connecting the audience with any character on screen. As we patiently seat till the interval and witness a potent twist at interval, our hopes are ignited again that the movie can pick up after interval.

But… again the but comes into the picture…. and no mercy…. the fools which we are, spend so much money time and hope for a small demand of engrossing entertainment from the biggest are again let down by the Director Anil Sharma and Writer duo Salman Khan and Shaktiman Talwar.

The movie does not take off…. in-fact it goes down the drain spirally making us a VEER to watch the movie till the end.

All those crores of rupees of producer Vijay Gilani, the hard work of Salman Khan and Mithoon (no one else actually care to act!), the exciting action by Tinu Verma and Peter Pedrero, the breathtaking cinematography by Gopal Shah, everything is just drained to gutter due to shoddy work of writing, direction, editing, music director (Sajid-Wajid), Costume Designer (Anna Singh).

Why do these people fail in such a big opportunity to create something worthwhile? Why don’t they work on script and screenplay more than directly going to shoot?

These can be questions kept unanswered because that’s the way Bollywood is.

The movie rides totally on Salman’s star power, all the whistles and claps are for him. He does work hard for this movie (which he normally doesn’t) and puts in sincere efforts. Mithoon is a delight to watch. Sohail Khan does monkey job and thinks it is funny. Everyone else is totally wasted. I wonder what the Adman and Hinglish Theater pioneer Bharat Dabholkar is doing in the background row of extra pindhari soldiers? And what was the veteran marathi theater actor Vinay Apate doing in the same row? Many known faces are there for one or two scenes. The new actress Zarin Khan has a big role but no future for sure.

The climax is blow on our intelligence and patience and makes us angry about being taken for granted as fools by the film makers. On the whole, its a big disappointment. Still I give the one extra star for the good rare moments in the film, Salman and Mithoon.

BR Rating : 2
BR Verdict : Below Average
BR Recommends : Watch only if you are ardent Salman and Mithoon fan!

  • Hi cheers for an incisive post, I actually found your blog by mistake while looking on Goole for something else closely connected, in any event before i ramble on too much i would just like to say how much I enjoyed your post, I have bookmarked your website and also taken your RSS feed, Once Again thanks for the blog post keep up the great work.
  • Bollywood | DharamVeer | Dharamvir | hindi films | Mithoon Chakraborti | Salman Khan | Veer | Veer Movie Review | Veer Review | Vir
  • Posted in Bollywood Movie Reviews, Hindi Film Review, Hindi Movie Review | No Comments »

Chance Pe Dance: No Chance!

January 16th, 2010

Sometimes we keep waiting for few movies. By the time its announced, we almost are convinced that it will be the best. The promoters, creative engines, performers, etc all are so solid with prover track record are enough to make us feel that it can not go wrong.Shahid Kapoor, Genelia D’souza with Ken Gosh. Film promoted by UTV. They can not get go wrong… right?

So when they come out with chance pe dance, the expectations are sky high (specially after stupendous run of Shahid at box office).

So let’s come to the story. The story is about a struggling talent aspiring to get a foothold in the hindi film industry (luck by chance?). The name is Sameer Behl (Shahid Kapoor). He is a great dancer and a super acting talent. The film starts with the never say die attitude of this struggler giving 100s of auditions in last 3 years. By the grace of God, he gets a chance for a music video which is snatched by another influential candidate. Nevertheless, he happens to meet a nice girl, Sonia Sharma (Genelia D’souza) who is choreographer by profession.

They again meet at another audition where Sameer is selected as Hero and she is working as choreographer. Sameer gets this biggest news of his life on the same day he is thrown out of his room by his landlord. Sameer starts living off his car and gets a day time job as dance teacher in school to suvive till his film starts only to know later that he is thrown out of the film and the director (Mohnish Behl) is trying to hunt his hero through a big talent hunt show.

With a broker heart, can Sameer manage to achieve his dream?

The story is nothing new. It’s the journey of the protagonist from a struggler to emerge as winner at the end. However, with Shahid’s dancing skills and the title of the film, someone can assume this to be dance film and to offer great dance sequences with engrossing storyline.

But sadly, the story never takes off… It keeps showing ups and downs in Sameer’s life repeatedly and has some improperly closed subplots like the school children track. The clear looser in this fair in the writing… the script and the screenplay (as always the case).

Unfortunately, the director Ken Ghosh could not cover the week screenplay with something extraordinary treatment. The movie keeps happening at a snail’s pace with no excitement to offer. We keep thinking now something will happen, but it never does. The writer lacked content and ideas and so does the director. It’s an unfortunate failed attempt.

On the performances side, everyone is good at his or her own place. They delivered what is demanded. Shahid puts genuine effort in the film. Dances well (though there could have been better choreography. We see better in TV shows now a days), acts well, tries to connect with the audience. But the writing fails him miserably. Same with Genelia. She has not given proper scope. In whatever she has got, she did justice to her role. Mohnish Behl, Parikshit Sahani are also ok. Satish Shah as the principle of the schools has a habit of keeping everything tidy but his character is cut short and never used properly. He does a good job as always.

The music could have been better for a film of such kind. Pee Pee is wasted at the start itself. The dance song at the schools is already a hit and shows dancing prowess of Shahid.

The cinematography, production quality are ok. The problem with this film is everything is just ok. Nothing much to offer.

The film has some good moments but those are not enough to suggest anyone to spend his hard earned money on expensive tickets.

So in short, I will not recommend this movie to anyone. May be dance lovers, Shahid fans can enjoy it much better.

BR Rating : *1/2
BR Verdict : Below Average
BR Recommends : Can’t Recommend to anyone…. sorry for that! I wanted this film to be good.

  • Posted in Bollywood Movie Reviews, Hindi Film Review, Hindi Movie Review | No Comments »

Bollywood News    |    Features and Specials    |    Movie Reviews    |    Moive Previews    |    Release Dates

All contents © copyright owned by www.bollywoodreviews.net. All rights reserved.

Valid XHTML 1.0 Transitional Valid CSS!